Not terribly well written, simplistic in several ways, but the characters are very compelling. I even wanted to reread right away because I wanted to spend more time with them. An author worth watching to see if she can free the great characters from her clunky prose.

Very good book. A lot more pleasent than what most modern teen books are like. A great book for moms and daughters to read together in my opinion.

Okay, this book was too good!! I liked it because it wasn't totally predictable like most books. The story itself was amazing!! Eilis, I would like more books. Great book.

I liked the book, but I thought that it was very steriotypical... Overall, I give it a 4.1 out of 5.

Good read

The book was lovely! i loved all the twist and turns, witchcraft and fairytaleness to the book!

Very good first half, but the pace in the second half dragged. Too much filler: "What if this or that, what is he/she doing now" and so on. Too much pondering filling up too many pages

This book was so good! the plot always kept you guessing and you never knew exactly how the story would end. it was a very unpredictible ending. Eilis o'Neal nded this book so well. you were not wanteign anything else at the end, she closed up the hole thing very well and left nothing out. she developed all the characters well throughout so that you felt that you knew them personally and how they would react to each new problem or situation. would recomend to anyone!!!

This is an overall nice book. It kept me hooked.

pretty good book, and a really clever lot idea. but i felt that it wasn't as engrossing as i expected it to be. also the romance wasn't as good. i couldn't understand Sinda. one second she was talking about how she loved kiernan, then a second later she was pushing him away. it didn't seem realistic.