I was surprised at how fun this read was. Sure it's light and predictable but it was fun and that made the journey worthwhile. I liked the end, I loved Lilly and Quince. They really were awsome. I did not see the first twist coming I honesty didn't and what I thought was going to be a predictable step by step romance novel turned out to be a pleasent surprise. A good beach or summer read. Highly recommended as long as you remember not to take it too seriously and have fun.

Not that great, but not too awful either. Worth a read because it's not very long, but don't hold it above priority on your reading lists. I found the beginning very promising, but the plot radically dwindled half way through.

This book is full of romance. So much it's overpowering. So much it gets a bit annoying. It goes back and forth between sea and land, and yet there is next to no adventure at all. I hate the main character (sorry, she annoys me), but the guy pining over her for very wishy-washy reasons is cool. I like him. Well, darn it all, because even though the book has a bad plot, I can't help but like it. I blame it on my teenaged hormones thirsty for any sort of romance, no matter how pathetic and dragged out it is. Yes, I hate this book. Yes, I like this book. I hate myself for liking it.

Fun summer read.

I loved this book! It was amazing!

Great book. Just loved it!

This was an Excellent Book. Refreshing ideas, watery concepts but soooo good. I was thrilled I came across it, and just the cover alone let me know that this was going to be something new. Well Well worth the few hours to read!

freakin' awesome!!! i loved it from the first page. i think readers can really identify with Lily's struggle to fit in, even a tottally syco case like me. a reaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaally great read.

Love it! I never thought I'd enjoy a mermaid book, but I did. It was a really fun read, and really cute :)

I LOVE THIS BOOK!!!!!!!!!!!! I CAN'T WAIT FOR THE NEXT ONE TO COME OUT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!